LETTER TO THE EDITOR

Over a Barrel

Posted

 

To the Editor,

Both Manchester and Gloucester began Casella automated trash and recycling pickup over the last few months, transforming our streetscapes with new large bins.  These bins are required because they meet the needs of automation: they can be lifted and emptied at the press of a button from inside Casella’s trucks.  They eliminate the need for a job once done by a human: tossing things into the truck.

Automation often comes with promises that it will make our lives more efficient: reducing our working hours, and increasing our leisure.  But layering technology over human tasks often does the opposite: rather than reducing labor, it shifts the burden onto other humans.  Historians found that the presence of machines in households, for example, increased standards for housekeeping: creating more work, typically done by women.  Getting customers to take on more labor is a cost-reduction strategy for companies.  “Customer service,” for example, that involves navigating an automated phone tree, or chatting with an AI “agent.”  Having students “learn” from an AI chatbot that can simulate language because language is a statistically predictable system, but – unlike an actual teacher – lacks any conceptual understanding of what a student is trying to express.

“Cart placement is key!” Casella tells us.  Automated systems often require a human-in-the-loop. We drag the bins in and out, and figure out where to store them.  Eliminating (paid) bag throwers transformed us all into (unpaid) Casella bin movers.  This burden falls unevenly: it is harder for older people, and anyone less strong, such as children who might have taken out the trash as part of their chores.  Gloucester’s landscape rises steeply from the Boulevard and Main and Rogers Streets.  The new automated trucks cannot do their thing in many of those dense neighborhoods.  In other places, the distance between home and the road is simply too far; so the bins stay out, changing the way things look.

During three long months in summer of 2025, more than 400 Republic Services sanitation workers struck for better wages and healthcare, alongside Teamsters also striking in Ohio and Georgia.  Republic is an Arizona-based Fortune 500 company that took over local trash collection in greater Boston in 2020, to some controversy.  It has tens of thousands of employees and makes tens of billions in revenue annually.  Casella, based in Rutland, Vermont and run by the family whose name it bears, is a publicly-traded company that posted $1.84 billion in revenue in 2025, and employs 4,000 people. 

Jettisoning Republic for Casella the same year as Gloucester, Manchester negotiated a clause in its contract to ensure Casella is responsible for covering any gaps in coverage like the summer of 2025.  But the overall trend towards corporate consolidation and automation leaves less competition and fewer choices, explaining industry-wide increases in cost.  The Manchester town manager described limited choices for trash and recycling pickup: “most new contracts included a 40% to 50% increase in Year 1, and a 5% annual increase over five years, and a requirement to incorporate automated collection and uniform barrels.”  That last requirement allows collection companies to increase their profit through the reduction of labor costs on their balance sheets. 

But seeing that the labor hasn’t been eliminated, so much as shifted onto the rest of us, is a helpful realization as we continue to debate the various forms of automation that the technologies of our age make available.

Hilary C. Robinson

Manchester

Opinion

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here